| Year | Champion | Site |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | James Nicholas | Huntington Crescent |
| 2022 | Reid Howey | Westhampton |
| 2021 | Andrew Svoboda | Fresh Meadow |
| 2020 | Jason Caron | Sands Point |
| 2019 | Andrew Svoboda | Hempstead |
| 2018 | Andrew Svoboda | Nassau |
| 2017 | J.D. Guiney | Westhampton |
| 2016 | Jimmy Hazen | Garden City CC |
| 2015 | Jim Farrell* | The Creek |
| 2014 | Jimmy Hazen | The Bridge |
| 2013 | Matt Dobyns | Fresh Meadow |
| 2012 | Michael Meehan* | Bethpage - Red |
| 2011 | Matt Dobyns | Wheatley Hills |
| 2010 | Mark Brown | Bethpage - Red |
| 2009 | Michael Meehan | Atlantic |
| 2008 | Michael Meehan | Bethpage - Red |
| 2007 | Abbie Valentine | Nassau |
| 2006 | Darrell Kestner | Bethpage - Red |
| 2005 | Bob Rittberger | Bethpage - Red |
| 2004 | Keith Blythe | Bethpage - Red |
| 2003 | Ron Faria | Bethpage - Red |
| 2002 | Bob Rittberger | Long Island National |
| 2001 | Rick Hartmann | Bethpage - Red |
| 2000 | Mark Mielke | Bethpage - Red |
| 1999 | Mark Mielke | Bethpage - Red |
| 1998 | Rick Hartmann | Bethpage - Red |
| 1997 | Rick Hartmann | Bethpage - Red |
| 1996 | Tom McGinnis | Bethpage - Red |
| 1995 | Darrell Kestner | Bethpage - Red |
| 1994 | Rick Hartmann | Bethpage - Red |
| 1993 | Bruce Zabriski | Bethpage - Red |
| 1992 | Rick Meskell* | Bethpage - Red |
| 1991 | Bruce Zabriski | Bethpage - Red |
| 1990 | Tom Sutter | Bethpage - Red |
| 1989 | Bruce Zabriski | Bethpage - Red |
| 1988 | Jim Albus | Bethpage - Red |
| 1987 | Jim Albus | Hempstead |
| 1986 | Rick Vershure | Cherry Valley |
| 1985 | Bruce Zabriski | Cedarbrook |
| 1984 | Tom Joyce | Cedarbrook |
| 1983 | Don Reese* | Huntington |
| 1982 | Mike Joyce | Fox Run |
| 1981 | Mal Galletta, Jr. | Noyac |
| 1980 | Don Beatty | Fox Run |
| 1979 | Mal Galletta, Jr. | St. George's |
| 1978 | Roger Ginsberg | Huntington Crescent |
| 1977 | Mal Galletta, Jr. | St. George's |
| 1976 | Dave Matthews | Westhampton |
| 1975 | Tom Nieporte* | Nassau |
| 1974 | Jim Wright | Woodmere |
| 1973 | Tom Nieporte | Pine Hollow |
| 1972 | Jim Wright | Harbor Hills |
| 1971 | Gene Borek | Hempstead |
| 1970 | Jim Wright | Inwood |
| 1969 | Jim Wright | North Hills |
| 1968 | Jerry Pittman | Woodmere |
| 1967 | Pete Mazur | Rockville Links |
| 1966 | Gene Borek | Fresh Meadow |
| 1965 | Tom Nieporte | Piping Rock |
| 1964 | Tom Nieporte | Rockaway Hunting |
| 1963 | Art Silverstone | Muttontown |
| 1962 | Tom Nieporte | Garden City CC |
| 1961 | Ed Merrins | Westhampton |
| 1960 | Bob Stuhler | North Hempstead |
| 1959 | Al Brosch | Rockville |
| 1958 | John Cleary | Meadow Brook |
| 1957 | Shelley Mayfield | Woodmere |
| 1956 | Al Brosch | St. George's |
| 1955 | Art Doering | Great River |
| 1954 | Jay Hebert | Southward Ho |
| 1953 | Al Brosch | Meadow Brook |
| 1952 | Fred Wampler | North Hempstead |
| 1951 | Al Brosch | Plandome |
| 1950 | Al Brosch | Meadow Brook |
| 1949 | Al Brosch | Willow Brook |
| 1948 | Al Brosch | Garden City CC |
| 1947 | Al Brosch | Brookville |
| 1946 | Al Brosch | Hempstead |
| 1945 | Henry Ransom | Wheatley Hills |
| 1942-'44 No Competition | ||
| 1941 | Pat Cici | Lido |
| 1940 | Joe Turnesa | Inwood |
| 1939 | Al Brosch | Wheatley Hills |
| 1938 | Joe Turnesa | Rockville |
| 1937 | Jim Barnes | Huntington Crescent |
| 1936 | Charles Lacey | Rockville |
| 1935 | Jimmy Hines | Fresh Meadow |
| 1934 | Joe Turnesa | Lakeville |
| 1933 | Willie Klein | Lido |
| 1932 | Walter Kozak | Garden City CC |
| 1931 | MacDonald Smith | Southward Ho |
| 1930 | MacDonald Smith | Engineers |
| 1929 | MacDonald Smith | Salisbury |
| 1928 | George Voigt | Salisbury |
| 1927 | Gene Sarazen | Salisbury |
| 1926 | James B. Law | Salisbury |
| 1925 | MacDonald Smith | Salisbury |
| 1924 | James Maiden | St. Albans |
| 1923 | Willie Klein | Garden City CC |
| 1922 | Willie Klein | Cherry Valley |
*Winner - 3 hole aggregate playoff